ABOUT COMPLETE-CAREERS

Empowering people to make successful transitions and achieve their career potential.

Complete-Careers brings together dedicated Level 6 and 7 trained careers professionals with more than 100 years of combined knowledge, experience and expertise in careers education and guidance for young people and adults.

OUR MISSION

We constantly innovate to empower people to make successful transitions and achieve their full potential.

OUR VALUES

The principles that shape how we work

01

Collaboration

02

Diversity

03

Empowerment

04

Environmental

05

Professional Integrity

06

Social Mobility

07

Transparency

OUR PARTNERS

Meet the people leading Complete Careers

John Ambrose

Jenny Beaumont

NEED CAREERS SUPPORT?

Talk to our careers experts

Whether you are an education provider, organisation or individual, our team can help you find the right support.

 

QUALITY IN CAREERS STANDARD

Career Mark

Complete Careers is a Licensed Awarding Body for the Quality in Careers Standard through its unique Career Mark approach. For 30 years, Career Mark has had an excellent reputation in supporting learning providers to quality assure and develop their careers programme.

(We also have a Career Mark Primary Award dedicated to supporting, developing and accrediting primary schools to deliver a high quality careers program to their pupils.)

The quality in careers standard logo

READY TO GET STARTED?

Sign up for Career Mark

To get started with the Career Mark, register for an account with us. You will then have access to the members area of the website and the Career Mark Courses.

Our Services

Continuous Professional Development

Both accredited (levels 4 and 6) and non-accredited bespoke training delivery on all matters careers, employability and workforce development

Our Services

Guidance & Community

 Direct delivery for clients of all ages to empower them to reach their career potential.

Our Services

Quality Assurance

Facilitating organisational continuous improvement through our long-term quality association with quality award recognition and the Quality in Careers Standard for schools and colleges.”

NEED CAREERS SUPPORT?

Talk to our careers experts

Whether you are an education provider, organisation or individual, our team can help you find the right support.

 

LEARNER SUPPORT

Resources

Practical resources, tools and guidance designed to support learners and career professionals.

Books, cards and classroom resources

COMPLETE CAREERS SHOP

Practical resources to support careers conversations and learning.

From a Welfare State to a Working State

From a Welfare State to a Working State: Summary and commentary of Alan Milburn’s November 26 report

The Alan Milburn report: From a Welfare State to a Working State was published on 17th November and sets out wide scale proposals for the government to review to address the young people and NEET crisis over the next decade.  The report is 278 in length, with 1006 paragraphs, with the executive summary alone 36 pages.  I have studied the executive summary and scanned the main report with a focus on education and skills and have summarised the main components below, along with a brief commentary at the end.  

The Scale of the Challenge

The report argues that the UK faces a significant crisis in youth participation in education, employment and training. It identifies poverty and inequality as being at the heart of the growing NEET (Not in Education, Employment or Training) challenge.   See here for my initial May 2026 interim report summary which sets out the scale of the challenge:  https://complete-careers.com/young-people-and-work-a-scathing-report-on-the-present-an-ironic-disregard-of-the-past-with-the-future-or-recommendations-yet-to-be-determined/ 

The review presents an ambitious long-term objective of reducing the proportion of young people who are NEET to around 5% by 2036. It further introduces the concept of “NEET Zero”, arguing that every young person who is able to participate in education, employment or training should be doing so. 

A particular concern is the 57,000 16- and 17-year-olds who are currently NEET despite being legally required to participate, alongside thousands more whose status is unknown. 

Five System Failures

The introduction identifies five major failures that have contributed to the current situation.

1. Labour Market Failure

The labour market has become less favourable for young people, with the report arguing that: “The first rung on the career ladder has eroded.”  Young people increasingly struggle to access entry-level employment and gain initial workplace experience. 

2. Education System Failure

The report argues that the education system is not consistently providing young people with the aptitudes, employability skills and broader capabilities required for a rapidly changing labour market.  Qualifications alone are not enough; young people need greater readiness for work and life. 

3. Health System Failure

The health system is criticised for focusing too heavily on treatment rather than prevention, particularly in relation to young people’s mental health and wellbeing. 

4. Welfare System Failure

The welfare system is seen as asking: “What can’t you do?” rather than “What can you do?” The report argues that too many young people are moved into long-term benefit dependency instead of receiving support to participate in education, work and training. 

5. Fragmented Government Failure

Responsibility is spread across multiple agencies, programmes and levels of government. The report argues that there is no genuinely integrated system for supporting young people.  

New Localised Approach

A central theme of the report is the devolution of power and responsibility.  It aligns with the Government’s wider agenda of “rewiring the state” by creating a more locally led system in which:

  • Schools and colleges
  • Employers
  • Combined authorities and mayors
  • Local authorities
  • Families and communities

share responsibility for improving youth participation and employment outcomes. 

Youth Opportunity Service (YOS)

Central to the report is a proposal for a new Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) in every area of England to join up support for young people. Strategic authorities would be given responsibility for overseeing the entire 16-24 participation system. 

‘Young people who are NEET should be helped by the new Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) into participation. This should be responsible for delivering the Guarantees.’ (paragraph 104 – main report)

‘Its purpose (YOS) should be to make sure that a young person who is outside education or work, or at serious risk of becoming so, has somewhere to go and somebody responsible for helping them move forward.’ (Paragraph 122 – main report)

‘The YOS should not provide every service itself but make the system work around the young person rather than expecting the young person to navigate it.’ (paragraph 123 – main report)

‘The YOS should be built primarily from the people and organisations already supporting young people, rather than by creating an entirely new bureaucracy.’ (paragraph 124 – main report)

‘The Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) should become the local front door through which employers can access young people and get the help they need to sustain them in work’ (paragraph 293 – main report)

‘The YOS would also organise work experience brokerage where schools and colleges cannot secure enough opportunities themselves’. (paragraph 293 – main report)

‘Through a simple front door, young people should be able to see the full range of opportunities available locally, understand where they lead, and obtain additional support from the YOS where needed’ (paragraph 474 – main report)

‘From the first day of their interaction with the YOS, the young person will be assigned an adviser.’ (paragraph 556 – main report)

‘The YOS will be locally led and organised differently in different places. It will draw on staff and services from local authorities, the Jobs and Careers Service, Careers Hubs, health services, colleges, voluntary organisations and other providers. (Paragraph 835 – main report).

‘Careers support will be a core YOS function, not a parallel architecture’ (paragraph 840 – main report)

Local areas (strategic authorities) should begin preparation for the YOS immediately with an expectation for a local area Participation Plan and central functions of the YOS to be mobilised by 2027/28.

Education Recommendations

Preventing Young People Becoming NEET

The report argues that schools remain too focused on academic attainment and not sufficiently focused on preparation for employment and adulthood. 

Early Years

The report recommends increasing school readiness to:

  • 90% of children by age 5
  • Up from the current target of approximately 75%. 

Identifying Risk Earlier

It proposes:

  • A mandatory participation and transition plan for every pupil identified as being at risk.
  • Participation indicators becoming mandatory within both primary and secondary education. 

Literacy, Numeracy and Oracy

A new national assessment framework for key stage 3 would be introduced for Literacy, Numeracy and Oracy.  Schools would also be given discretion over 10% of curriculum time to meet local needs. 

Work Experience and Careers Education

The importance of work experience features throughout with calls to make work experience a statutory duty (paragraph 65 – main report)

Schools and colleges will retain their current responsibilities for careers education and guidance, with the YOS providing the infrastructure around them.  (paragraph 840 -main report).  What becomes more confusing is who is responsible for what.  Paragraph 437 of the main report states the ‘Government should ensure that every school and young person can access high-quality digital careers information, including AI-enabled tools, which bring together national and local labour-market information, pathways and earnings data in an accessible form. Technology should free more face-to-face capacity for young people who need it most, allowing young people at risk of becoming NEET to receive enhanced face-to-face guidance at the main decision points, with parents involved where appropriate.’

It is clear that the intention is to move existing local careers hubs into the new YOS (paragraph 840 – main report)

A new national “Ready for Work Standard” would be introduced to assess whether young people leave education with the confidence, skills and behaviours needed for the next stage of their lives.

Work-readiness measures would:

  • Be published publicly.
  • Be inspected by Ofsted.
  • Form part of a new school outcome framework that is easier for parents and learners to understand. 

Further Education and Apprenticeships

The report proposes:

Pre-Apprenticeships

  • An initial 25,000 pre-apprenticeship places.
  • A pathway towards significantly expanding apprenticeship participation among under-25s by 2036. 

Increased FE Participation

A major expansion of further education opportunities for 18-24-year-olds.

College Incentives

A new Participation and Work-Readiness Premium for colleges supporting:

  • 16–17-year-olds who are NEET.
  • Young people identified as being at risk of becoming NEET. 

Return of EMA

The report recommends the return of the Education Maintenance Allowance (EMA) in a Care Leaver Transition Allowance of £50 per week proposed to support engagement and progression. 

Reforming the Growth and Skills Levy

The Growth and Skills Levy should be reoriented towards younger learners, with all its funding directed towards young people. 

Employer Recommendations

Making Recruitment of Young People Easier

The report outlines five employer-focused objectives:

  1. Make it financially worthwhile to employ young people.
  2. Provide employers with a single route into support services.
  3. Remove unnecessary regulatory and practical barriers.
  4. Ensure government leads by example as an employer.
  5. Use public procurement to create more first-job opportunities. 

Financial Incentives

Proposals include:

  • National Insurance relief for employers recruiting 21-24-year-olds in sectors such as retail and hospitality.
  • £3,000 incentive payments for recruiting a young person who has been NEET for six months or more.
  • An additional £2,000 for recruiting a young person facing significant barriers, such as disability.
  • A further £2,000 payment for small employers. 

Health and Welfare Reform

Faster Access to Support

Young people who are NEET would receive faster access to services including:

  • Vocational rehabilitation
  • Talking therapies
  • Counselling

where they are engaging with the Youth Opportunity Service.  The report also proposes a new mental health “front door” to create a more joined-up and accessible system. 

Opportunity and Support Guarantees

The report proposes two new statutory guarantees.

Opportunity Guarantee

A legal entitlement to Education, Training or Employment support opportunities

for all young people. 

Support Guarantee

A legal entitlement to coordinated support including health services, employment support, functional skills support and practical assistance to help young people access and sustain those opportunities.   Delivery would be led locally through the new Youth Opportunity Service. 

Brief commentary

The report sets out the recommendations to government to tackle the NEET crisis over the next decade, but it is difficult to see clearly how this will happen.  This is partly due to the structure of the report (there isn’t a list of recommendations at the end for example) and partly because it will be applied differently in each local area.  

It will remain to be seen which aspects of the report the government will implement, but given the media attention, soundbites from the PM and Ministers and existing plans for greater devolved powers, I would expect YOS to be the acronym of 2027.

The report introduces large scale reforms to tackle the NEET crisis, breaking down societal structures in the process.  There is clearly much needed support for employers and schools and colleges, but the ‘NEET Zero’ target is very ambitious to say the least.  

For those of us who have been working in careers for 20 years or more it is difficult not to make comparisons to the Connexions service initiative from 2000 to 2010.  This was a wrap around service to help young people overcome participation barriers.  The YOS doesn’t seem to be a single service though, but the language is similar.  Connexions was about ensuring no child slipped through the net of services, while the new YOS is about connecting services for NEET young people or those at risk of becoming NEET.  

Connexions was a ‘one stop shop’, while YOS is to be the ‘front door’ for every NEET young person to access support.   

Plenty of course can change in politics between now and 2036, so much will depend on the next general election and thereafter, as well as how local strategic authorities approach this.  

John Ambrose

Director, Complete-Careers LLP

Featured image: Cover of From a Welfare State to a Working State. © Crown copyright 2026. Licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

The opinions expressed in our blogs are not necessarily those of complete careers LLP but are the opinions of the identified author.

We have launched our new Career Mark Members Area. If you are a member and have not already done so, please click this link to re-set your password and gain access.